Do Low Taxes Lead to Entrepreneurial Growth?

State

Small Business Survival Index Ranking
(See Note 1)

Entrepreneurial Energy as defined by 
the Corporation for Enterprise Development

New Company Starts
(2)

Change in New Companies (3)

New Business Job Growth (4)

Technology Companies (5) 

Initial Public Offerings (6)

Alabama

8

41

34 21 37 38

Alaska

14

13

33 41 38 8

Arizona

20

29

38 5 13 31

Arkansas

25

45

46 47 46 32

California

44

2

13 7 5 5

Colorado

11

3

42 6 2 12

Connecticut

33

31

37 50 5 17

Delaware

29

9

36 13 22 41

Florida

5

10

6 8 19 20

Georgia

23

15

29 24 15 1

Hawaii

49

27

47 48 40 26

Idaho

26

7

16 3 42 35

Illinois

13

43

15 34 10 13

Indiana

16

44

23 39 29 36

Iowa

39

50

43 16 48 41

Kansas

47

30

4 37 27 21

Kentucky

32

38

19 4 41 40

Louisiana

19

33

35 45 33 41

Maine

48

11

32 43 29 6

Maryland

27

17

39 18 5 14

Massachusetts

21

35

41 19 1 3

Michigan

12

32

7 21 19 11

Minnesota

46

46

45 30 9 23

Mississippi

9

39

22 26 47 22

Missouri

17

36

27 10 33 4

Montana

38

8

12 33 42 30

Nebraska

31

47

26 39 44 41

Nevada

1

4

18 9 14 24

New Hampshire

7

12

50 15 4 25

New Jersey

37

20

31 27 3 16

New Mexico

45

28

44 38 25 41

New York

43

18

20 36 22 2

North Carolina

35

19

3 23 29 27

North Dakota

24

48

21 35 50 41

Ohio

40

49

30 31 17 37

Oklahoma

28

21

8 29 17 7

Oregon

36

14

49 13 21 19

Pennsylvania

22

37

17 32 22 10

Rhode Island

50

15

5 44 25 34

South Carolina

18

23

9 28 38 39

South Dakota

2

40

24 42 49 41

Tennessee

10

25

25 25 36 29

Texas

6

34

40 12 12 9

Utah

34

5

14 1 11 28

Vermont

42

24

48 11 28 41

Virginia

15

22

28 17 8 18

Washington

3

1

10 2 16 15

West Virginia

41

26

1 46 44 41

Wisconsin

30

42

2 20 29 33

Wyoming

4

6

11 49 33 41

Notes of Sources

1. Small Business Survival Index 2001: http://www.sbsc.org  -- 17 factors are used to develop the overall rankings: personal income taxes, capital gains taxes, corporate income taxes, property taxes, sales taxes, estate taxes, unemployment taxes, health insurance taxes, electricity costs, workers' compensation costs, crime rates, right-to-work status, number of government employees, tax limitation status, Internet taxes, gas taxes, and state minimum wages.

Columns 2-6 are from the Development Report Card for the States: 2000 The descriptions and sources listed below are taken directly from the web version of the report. The "we" reference is to the Corporation for Enterprise Development.

2. New Companies 
New company formation is one of the principle ways we measure entrepreneurial energy. New firms are defined as those that seek new account numbers from state employment services. Measure: Number of companies applying for new employment service account numbers, 1998, per 1,000 1998 workers. Source: U.S. Small Business Administration, Office of Advocacy, from the Council of Economic Advisers, Economic Indicators, March 1998 and March 1999 and the Bureau of Labor Statistics. 

3. Change in New Companies 
This measure examines the trend in new company formations on a year-to-year basis. 
Measure: Percentage of change in companies applying for new employment service account numbers, from 1997 to 1998. Source: U.S. Small Business Administration, Office of Advocacy, from the Council of Economic Advisers, Economic Indicators, March 1998 and March 1999 and the Bureau of Labor Statistics. 

4. New Business Job Growth 
A good indicator of the impact of entrepreneurship in a state is the job growth associated with relatively young businesses. This measure gives a picture of the influence of local entrepreneurs on a state economy through the creation of new jobs. Measure: Percent growth in employment at firms less than five years old, 1993-1998. Source: David Burch, Jan Gundersen, Anne Haggerty, and William Parsons. Who's Creating Jobs? Cognetics, Inc. Cambridge, MA: 1999. 

5. Technology Companies 
The size of this sector creates more opportunities for clustering, agglomeration economies, and dynamic interactions that increase the chances of producing commercially successful companies. Measure: Percentage of business establishments that are technology companies, 1997. Source: U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of the Census. County Business Patterns, 1997. Washington D.C.: 2000. 

6. Initial Public Offerings 
The number and/or value of initial public offerings is an excellent indicator of the growth potential of these small companies. The rate and value of IPOs reflects the competitiveness of the state's small business sector. While many innovative and successful companies choose to remain under private ownership, companies that tap into the vast capital resources of the financial markets generate the largest absolute gains in employment and revenue. Measure: Proceeds of initial public offering, per business establishment, in dollars.
1999. Source: 1999 IPO Activity by State. Thomson Financial Securities Data. Accessed
July 2000.


State Science & Technology Institute
5015 Pine Creek Drive
Westerville, OH 43081
Phone: (614) 901-1690
Fax: (614) 901-1696
Email: ssti@ssti.org

  © 2002 State Science and Technology Institute. All rights reserved.